It is a right that encompasses within its broad domain the right to legal aid, right to a clean environment, and a plethora of other rights. A agrees to sell his immovable property to b for rs. Students name date of hearing 1 1 14007001001 aditya kumar 23. Will be displayed will not be displayed will be displayed. Aruna ramachandra shanbaug, a 60 year old female patient was examined on. Shanbaug, 60, a former nurse, was beaten and sexually assaulted in 1973 by a co worker, a. Mr justice sales, drawing on concessions made by the home office, has found that the correct approach is a two stage one whereby the rules must first be considered and then human rights must be separately considered afterwards. On 7 march 2011, the supreme court, in a landmark judgement, issued a set of broad. Nonprofit, apolitical, independent, and nongovernmental in nature, the uia has been a pioneer in the research. Scs arunachal judgment enriches jurisprudence in india. The case was discussed in 379th seiaa meeting dtd 24.
Everything you need to know about aruna shanbaug, whose. Per the honble the chief justice sri kalyan jyoti sengupta this appeal is directed against a portion of the judgment and order of the learned tribunal dated 22. Unfortunately the judgment in the case not only fails to grapple adequately with these issues, but also betrays faulty legal reasoning and an utter disregard for the law and the legal process. The dean, kem hospital is requested to file an affidavit stating his.
The case before us is a writ petition under article 32 of the constitution, finally, we have given our opinion in the case of aruna shanbaug. These include the medical reports of the alleged rape victim ms. Moreover, throughout their briefing in support of the motion to amend the judgment. Arathi rao from 2004 to 2009 showing she has had 4.
Aruna ramachandra shanbaug, a 60yearold female patient was examined on 28th january 2011, morning and 3rd february 2011, in the sideroom of ward4, of the k. Euthanasia is currently legal in the netherlands, switzerland and the united states. India court rejects aruna shanbaug euthanasia plea bbc news. The union of international associations uia is a research institute and documentation centre, based in brussels. This case placed the authority to decide whether a case is fit or not for euthanasia in the hands of the court. The court has considered the papers filed in support of and in opposition to this motion, as well as the argument of counsel for each party. Upnaai elects 20102011 board dean tuazon inducts 20102011 board of directors dinner dance, hyatt regency, garden grove, aug. District court for the northern district of california dismissed a declaratory judgment complaint filed by impax against medicis, ruling t.
She testified that she was dismissed by the respondent for pregnancy related reasons. This matter comes before the court on plaintiff getty images, inc. Refusing mercy killing of aruna shanbaug, lying in a vegetative state for 37 years in a mumbai hospital, a twojudge bench of justices markandeya katju and gyan sudha mishra, laid a. A new listing decision, based upon current information, is required. Is the formation of the jv between nora and sakari the best option for both companies to achieve their respective objectives. The case before us is a writ petition under article 32 of the constitution, and has been filed on behalf of the petitioner, aruna ramachandra shanbaug by one ms pinki virani of mumbai, as a next friend.
The supreme court judgement on transgender rights nalsa vs union of india a summary of the 15th april 2014 judgement, by danish sheikh the scope of the judgment this judgement covers persons who want to identify with the third gender as well as persons who want to transition from one identity to another, i. The supreme courts verdict on friday legalising passive euthanasia owes much to the aruna shanbaug case, around. The infamous jain hawala case and the indian establishments persistent refusal to face the truth has once again come into focus with the arrest of hurriyat leader ali shah geelani. Union of india raises important questions about the meaning of life, death and their relationship to law and to state power. Analysis essay case study norasakari a proposed jv in. The reader is asked to presume its presence wherever convent. She had been sexually assaulted brutally in november 1973 by. Aruna shanbaug case laid foundation for verdict the new indian. The board issued its findings of facts, conclusions of law, and order detailing its determination that a new york city department of education doe custodian. Aruna ramchandra shanbaug 1 june 1948 18 may 2015, was an indian nurse who was at. Ipc sections 143, 188, 283, 341, other details special cjm, allahabad case no. Aruna shanbaug judgement pdf united pdf comunication.
Lok sabha elections 2014 details of criminal cases self. It is stated in the writ petition that the petitioner aruna ramachandra shanbaug was a staff nurse working in king edward memorial hospital. Union of india, 2014 9 scc 1 constitution of india arts. The decision to open the door to assisted suicide is likely to be controversial, our correspondent adds. This led journalistactivist pinky virani, who published a book regarding her case, titled arunas story, to file a writ petition with the supreme court. The top court had in 2011 recognised passive euthanasia in aruna shanbaug case by. With due respects, with the greatest of respects, in deep reverence and in all and every humility, it is necessary now to say one ignorantly given sc judgment is wreaking havoc across india. Probably the most important fundamental right in the indian constitution is the right to life under article 21. On 23 august 1939 the soviet union hereafter at times referred to as the ussr, led by josef stalin, signed a nonaggression treaty with.
A summary of the claimants case is that the claimant is a company incorporated under the relevant laws of nigeria with its head office at plot 1679, karimu kotun street, victoria island, lagos and has branchessites in portharcourt, warri. A central bureau of investigation cbi court at ghaziabad gave death sentence to surinder koli and moninder singh pandher on monday in connection with one of the 16 cases of rape, murder. Fundamental rights are necessary for leading a dignified and fulfilling life. Aruna shanbaug died in may 2015, but her case helped in shedding light on an extremely complex issue of medical ethics and law. Program policydirectives master set with case history files official files. The supreme courts decision this week in aruna shanbaug v. Consideration sec 2d quid pro quo something in return something of value received by promisee as inducement of promise. The case involves a possible joint venture with sakari, the leading manufacturer in finland of mobile phones and telecom systems. Landmark judgment in swami nithyananda case nithyananda. One ignorantly given sc judgment is wreaking havoc across. In exercise of the powers conferred by section 2 h. Pages in category 1978 in case law the following 25 pages are in this category, out of 25 total. From the pleadings, the case of the claimants is that the federal government of nigeria sometime in 2003 introduced and directed all government ministries, agencies, departments and parastatals to implement monetization of fringe benefits for civil and public servants alike.
Geelani was arrested last month on charges of acting as a conduit for funding terrorism. The prefatory salutations are dispensed with in the rest of this piece to ease reading. The high court has endorsed the controversial approach of the upper tribunal towards the new immigration rules on human rights. Express photoamong the reasons, which led to the trial in the nayana pujari gangrape and murder case stretching on for over seven years, was the escape of prime accused yogesh raut from. While there is no legal difficulty in the case of the former, the latter poses. High court rejects mays high politics free movement. In landmark decision, supreme court allows passive euthanasia. In a landmark judgement, supreme court recognised that a terminallyill. Judgment of the supreme court of india on aruna shambag case. Dhillon, 1971 2 scc 779, there are dicta against referring to the speeches in the constituent assembly and in the last mentioned case they were referred to as supporting the conclusion already arrived at. Aruna shanbaug, once a nurse at kem hospital and then a patient for 42 years, lost her agonizing battle with life on monday.
In a landmark judgment in the swami nithyananda case, the honble high court of karnataka has ordered for the production of all the documents and evidences that had been collected by the police but not yet produced to the court. Record of proceedings petitions for special leave to appeal c2014 cc nos. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case, whether the income tax. Aruna shanbaug judgement pdf the supreme court on friday declared that its judgment in the case of aruna shanbaug is flawed. There are a large number of judgements on this point, including one by a. The case in brief is that, on 2509 secretary of ms. Pinki viranis lawyer, shubhangi tulli, decided not to file an appeal, saying the.
1240 227 460 672 1122 722 64 923 1168 257 1393 826 1274 1532 1402 791 719 1285 89 1051 117 642 1473 278 1413 524 42 914 1380 523 291 440 290 1053 263 372 251 1228 436 621 330 214 769 793 668 634 62 114 1480 1252 643